AllPhoneDeals.com

Rousing and thoughtful adventure

Customer Rating:
I enjoyed this book so much more than I thought I would--having heard that it is offensive to Native American. I do not mean this offensively, but I think I would have to have all that offends pointed out to me.

However, I found this a truly fascinating story of survival and the beauty of the natural world. It's a fairly classic story of a friendship between two very different boys, but as usual and as wonderfully they find similarities.

Speare draws from Robinson Crusoe to make comparisons in this story--I thought that was a nice touch. But she herself as a wonderful gift with words that makes this a beautiful and spirited story.

Also, as a teacher I could not help but love the scenes where reading was taught. It appealed to me.

A Realistic Picture of Pioneer Days Without Being Mawkish or PC

Customer Rating:
Speare gives a realistic picture of the edgy but generally humane interactions between the Native Americans and the European settlers. SOTB is unstintingly honest but not depressingly so, and is interesting in its description of life in those days. And it gives many interesting details about life as lived in earlier and simpler times. I enjoyed reading it to my kids and they seemed to enjoy it too. Recommended.

Sign of the Beaver Book Review

Customer Rating:
I rmember reading this book as a child, so when I found it again as an adult, I knew I HAD to have it again.

Perpetuates Stereotypes

Customer Rating:
As a fourth grade educator, I would never introduce this book to my students as anything else other than an example of popular culture that perpetuates stereotypes of Native Americans. Attean and other Native American characters speak in broken English, giving the reader the impression that these characters are inferior to their White counterparts. The terminology used is highly offensive (squaw)for both Native people and for women. The relationship that Attean has with girls in his tribe as well as with animals is unrealistic and down right inaccurate. Joseph Bruchac and Michael Dorris are two authors which do an excellent job of writing from the Native American perspective.

One of the greatest literary adventures of my childhood.

Customer Rating:
This book is captivating and impossible to put down even now as I approach age 30. As a girl I found it spellbinding, the kind of book that makes your own world and time dissolve around you and casts directly in the life and time of the characters. It is far to rare that an author can weave that kind of story. Elizabeth George Speare certainly has that gift. Don't hesitate to buy this for the children in your life. Also by E. G. Speare be sure and check out The Witch of Blackbird Pond and one of my all-time favorites, Calico Captive. Enjoy and keep a clock nearby as you're surely going to lose track of time while reading this book.